How not to review an award winning book Lesson 1:
Take a Cast:
Tom Paulin. Jaded hack poet. Ever read anything by him? Thought not.
Dominic Lawson no relation to Nigella. Never mind
Craig Brown (the satirist, not the footie manager)
Miranda umm errr Sawyer?, y'know.
Ensure none of the cast have read the book which has just netted 50
grand or thereabouts....
DL:.. the XMen and Ghost World were adapted from comic books and
the mainstream acceptability of a form associated with children has now
spread to the novel.
[Cut away to silent footage of someone presenting an award. Chris Ware
walks up to the mic and is clearly doing a very funny morose deadpan
acceptance speech. Which we can't hear]
Last night the Guardian First Book Award was presented to a novel in
the form of a comic strip, Chris Ware's "Jimmy Corrigan The Smartest
Kid On Earth". [Shot of first few pages] About a middle aged man in
Chicago whose comic book hero comes to life [shot of pages where
Superman actor seduces Jimmy's mum]. Although Art Spigelman's
Maus, a comic book about Auschwitz won the Pulitzer Prize in America
nine years ago [shot of pretty rare looking archive hardback of Maus
sitting on a table, then three whole panels of Maus]. This is the first time
that the British literary awards have allowed such a broad definition of
fiction. Starting a debate about whether the worlds of the Booker and
The Beano can merge. [Three more fast shots of "Jimmy...", then back
to the studio.]
Craig Brown, can a comic book be a novel?
CB: Certainly, I thought Posy Simmonds' "Gemma Bovery" was a
complete masterpiece. It certainly should have won the Turner or the
Booker or both. They certainly can. The only thing that slightly worries
me about this book is that, and about Maus, is that people like giving
prizes to gloomy... ahh.. comic novels.. ahh.. comic book book novels..
and actually I think the form works better with Tintin or Posy Simmonds,
where it's light and funny and breezy.
DL: Tom Paulin, does it count for you as a novel?
TP: the colours are dreadful, it's like looking at a bottle of Domestos or
Harpic or Ajax. Awful bleak colours, revolting to look at, it's on it's way to
the Oxfam shop.
DL: I understand why the judges went for this, Miranda, because the if
you look at the kind of invention and structure there is in cinema and
television and music. And the novel is still a very conventional form, and
you understand why they've done this, but did this one work?
MS: Well, I mean I haven't read it, but well the thing it reminded me of
was un eh Dave Eggers book, y'know, the det, the attention to detail, the
kind of like little dedications, and, and, the kind of nerd boy attitude
towards it, and I think that y'know obviously it's not a novel, but it can
definitely tell a story in the same way that "From Hell" told a really great
story and it was eventually turned into a film.
DL: What there are we judging, Craig, do you judge it on the pictures or
the words. I mean, could the words be rubbish and the pictures carry it
or...
CB: Well, I suspectwiththisbook its the other wayround. The
picturesdon't particularlyappealtome, they're they're they. Especially the
actual people, I don't like those, while Posy's people were so beautiful
and there was movement, not much movement in these..
TP: So ugly..
CB: I like what Miranda was saying, I like the obsessive quality.
MS: I like the pictures, I'd like to stick up for them.
TP: Disgusting look to it. Really orrible.
MS: I disagree.
[and cut.]
Broadcast live on the week's most respected big arts roundup on BBC
Newsnight at about 23:28 on the 8th December.